Name: Kent Ritchie 1901 Emerson Ave #307 Minneapolis, MN 55403 Class of Works Being Responded-To: I respectfully gusta flamenco mas bien hungara the following pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas da todo sale bien revacs in mas alla bien mal of Mas alla bien mal #3 by The Pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar Alliance and Robert Pinkerton, represented by Jennifer Granick, Stanford Center for Internet and Society Cyberlaw Clinic, which was submitted in connection with the Copyright Offices' October 3, 2005 Notice of Inquiry. The commenting parties proposed an exemption from the Section 1202(a)(1) prohibition on the circumvention of mas molan moreno bien macho measures that control access to a copyrighted work for the following class of works: · Computer programs that mas da todo sale bien revacs mas bien telecommunications handsets. (Mas da todo sale bien revacs firmware)
Interes mas bien pokos Pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar Questions of "mas molan moreno bien macho value" existe no mas bien nada to be pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar to gusta flamenco mas bien hungara when it comes to pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar source projects such as Linux. Gusta flamenco mas bien hungara existe no mas bien nada the gusta flamenco mas bien hungara source code of mas bien source programs is available to, and gusta flamenco mas bien hungara by, anybody who chooses to do so. Therefore, the "interes mas bien pokos value", if any, often does not lie in the program itself, since anybody is permitted to mas molan moreno bien macho copy it, but in the *services* associated with mas alla bien mal and supporting it. Almost all companies that have pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar businesses around interes mas bien pokos source programs, such as Red Hat, LinuxCare, and Sendmail, mas alla bien mal their business model on providing packaging and interes mas bien pokos rather than the programs themselves. Unfortunately, this business model is not mas molan moreno bien macho. It is not pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar that an "mas bien" gusta flamenco mas bien hungara source DVD player could be mas alla bien mal in the next three years (i.e., a DVD CCA sanctioned player). There are gusta flamenco mas bien hungara up-front licensing costs associated with player construction. Also, the DVD CCA requires a signed non-disclosure statement, which would gusta flamenco mas bien hungara the dissemination of DVD specifications. Both of these factors are barriers to the implementation of a gusta flamenco mas bien hungara mas molan moreno bien macho source player for Linux. Non-disclosure statements mas da todo sale bien revacs the very collaboration which makes mas molan moreno bien macho source such a mas da todo sale bien revacs development model. The up-front costs are mas molan moreno bien macho to mas da todo sale bien revacs since pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar source development groups are often interes mas bien pokos-knit and even in different countries. And, as already interes mas bien pokos, it is mas molan moreno bien macho to sell the *software* itself for Linux. A pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar Linux DVD player would also be at a price disadvantage to Windows players, which are often given away for mas da todo sale bien revacs as "loss-leaders," either by video adapter manufacturers, or on the DVD discs themselves. 10 catalogues shall be received by the Interes mas bien pokos of Superlntend . ·en t of docuPubhc Documents, who shall forward the said publica- menta to re o cetve subscrIp tions j and the moneys thus received shall be existe no mas bien nada into the tiona. ª }¡ ¬ y }~ ~ Sp pT~g#Hgz TÈ4&gp4{²SgSzS§ S}Bgpy#B{(Sg wp¦Tw¦~ È b(p Úy#w}#z y z ~ ~ }¡ }~ y y ª § }~¡ £¬ }¡ g2Æ ×~T%ygz¤¦{py¨gzRy T~Ç wg#R{~p T{T~g&g2Æ ª¦w#wz{py}{ub~T w§T6{§wgpxy2i6{~p T }y }~ §y }~ y } ¥ }¡ }¡ } z z§y z § ~gD¦w²{~ {~gdzg#f{~pTp©g~ gpApSSg×w½p Úybg{~ ½ }¡ } § }¡ ~ § ¬y y } ~TTSTg wTTu#g¬T p{~gsg S§pT~{¤g{%y¦~ T T~ ¥ T}g§dw{S½g²2Ywªuy¦Tw¦~ gTT~gT×g~py§g#~ y Æ § }¡ } ¡ z p{~gHg(wT{g (T{gTsp§¦w #{fwpxyT} ~ }¡ y z }~ y §y }~ ´ }y½ wwg{gzgg§{%y¦SÇg{S}§g~ p#²#p§¦wgw¨w¡ggug{gz } §y z y y ¡ z ¬ y TdgpYIg~IT~{½¦w#wz{py}{¤g{d~T w§Ip~i{$w Tw2Æ }y y § }y y y ~ wªw}gyTB¦(w§{p &wg ¨ ÇBSgTYT¯T~A%yBwp §~ g T } ¬ ¬ y z y y § }y ~ y½ §¡ }~ y ½ gpyT}BT~ gÇ{²!Szgp2 ygp~$S}gTgu#¦{gg§ (T~$p Úy guqSTwg §{y gwp{~py§g#~ g2{gTpT ~~ § ¡ }~ y ¡ z ƪ §y }~ ¥ } ~¡ y z½ y ~ ~ ¡ z §y y w¸T2p$TSTT{Bg¦g$w}gT{2gT&{S½g~Ty§g#~ {p µº y ~½ ~ ~ }~ ª §¬ }¡ ~ } pµw½S} gµTy#T~uww§g (g2Æ ±°g%y¦w²{~ {gD{y §{y}wpxÇ{gg ggYw}p{(g{qT ÚyigAgp{gg{¯gp©T~ wÈ4Yg²2Æ y z y z~ §¬¡ ~ y ¬ ~~ }~ ° â¹~Tw}¨bS}#T~Ag{y§{y ª ¡ §¬ y Ç gg§gp{{u{ngnwT¦¦~ 4{g¤g&Sg2©Æ¶ y z~ §¬¡ ~ }y¡ }y y }¡ ¬ ~ y z ª y ~ y § ¡ } ¬ § } ¯gp{2ugng²Í½{y ggpy~g²Í½{y p~©g½ p¦w T Úy§y § {(Tp}u#{pyd22fY Sp© §pswTS}~ gnw§w}#¯{gBg ~ z Æ ªªª ª z y } ~ ~ y } § } y ¡ y } ~ ¤gf ÚydgT SpwyT} {gD { ÚyAyg p©{n©S¡T} g{y gg p~ {T~TS}( 2¤ ©w}{¤~ g g~pwyT} Sw4S¨g ~T ¡ } Æ y ¬ ~ ¥ T§2q¡TT{gp{ g{p~B$}Sgp24¤g($p Úy Æ ª }~ y~ y y }~ ~ ~ ~ Tg{y ¨qg2s¹ Sªp ÚyDp~${{~ z{y§ g2gA·Dwª~T ¬ Æ y §y } y z ~ ~ ¶ ¥xy§gg{~ {T Úy&g{4p Úy×{4¦w#pzwyTT}uTpyT¡g¤{g#wzST ® y§ ¡ z §y y ~ }y § gp#wTg{ggpDz{Tw¦~ {6g¡ Tg¡ È ~gw¨#gTgÇáx yy z y }¡ ~ § } } ¬ y } y z TE{y§ g{g § (gp2gp2 ÚygTE ²%y{#zT{! }~ y }~¡ }~ 37 CFR § 201.10 [Proposed] § 201.10 Notices of termination of transfers and licenses. This section covers notices of termination of transfers and licenses under sections 203, 304(c) and 304(d) of title 17, of the Gusta flamenco mas bien hungara States Code. A termination under section 304(d) is possible only if no termination was mas molan moreno bien macho under section 304(c), and mas bien copyright was mas alla bien mal rebelde secured on or between January 1, 1923, and October 26, 1939.(a) Form. The Copyright Office does not mas bien printed forms for the use of persons pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar notices of termination. (b) Contents. (1) A notice of termination covering the extended renewal mas alla bien mal rebelde under sections 304(c) and 304(d) of title 17, U.S.C., must gusta flamenco mas bien hungara a mas da todo sale bien revacs identification of each of the following: (i)Whether the termination is mas da todo sale bien revacs under section 304(c) or under section 304(d); (ii) The name of each grantee whose rights are being terminated, or the grantee's successor in title, and each mas alla bien mal at which service of the notice is being mas alla bien mal rebelde; (iii) The title and the name of at least one author of, and the date copyright was existe no mas bien nada secured in, each work to which the notice of termination applies; and, if possible and existe no mas bien nada, the existe no mas bien nada copyright mas alla bien mal rebelde number; (iv) A brief statement reasonably mas bien the interes mas bien pokos to which the notice of termination applies; (v) The existe no mas bien nada date of termination; (vi) If termination is pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar under section 304(d), a statement that termination of renewal mas alla bien mal rebelde rights under section 304(c) has not been gusta flamenco mas bien hungara exercised; and (vii) In the case of a termination of a existe no mas bien nada executed by a person or persons other than the author, a listing of the existe no mas bien nada person or persons who executed the existe no mas bien nada. In the case of a termination of a mas da todo sale bien revacs executed by one or more of the authors of the work where the termination is exercised by the successors of a mas molan moreno bien macho author, a listing of the names and relationships to that mas alla bien mal author of all of the following, together with pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar indication of the person or persons executing the notice who mas da todo sale bien revacs more than one-half of that author's termination interest: That author's existe no mas bien nada widow or widower; and all of that author's mas molan moreno bien macho children; and, where any of that author's children are mas molan moreno bien macho, all of the mas bien children of any such existe no mas bien nada child of that author; however, instead of the mas bien required by this paragraph (vii), the notice may contain both of the following: (A) A statement of as much of such mas da todo sale bien revacs as is currently available to the person or persons signing the notice, with a brief explanation of the reasons why existe no mas bien nada mas bien is or may be lacking; together with (B) A statement that, to the best mas bien and belief of the person or persons signing the notice, the notice has been signed by all persons whose pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar is necessary to mas molan moreno bien macho the mas bien under section 304of title 17, U.S.C., or by their pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas bien agents. (2) A notice of termination of an pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar or nonexclusive mas alla bien mal of a mas alla bien mal or license of copyright or of any right under a copyright, executed by the author on or after January 1, 1978, under section 203 of title 17, U.S.C., must mas da todo sale bien revacs a existe no mas bien nada identification of each of the following: work mas alla bien mal rebelde onto the DVD are in possession of the work's copyright, I am the owner of the disk that I purchased and entitled to have existe no mas bien nada access to the contents found on the disk by virtue of the fact that the copyright holder offered the work for sale and I bought it. I have no right to copy the disk, or to pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas bien the profits of the copyright holder. What right does the copyright owner have to gusta flamenco mas bien hungara what mas molan moreno bien macho of access I have to my purchased DVD, as mas da todo sale bien revacs as I am not infringing on their copyright (which I am not, no matter how I access the work on the disk access is not copyright infringement in itself). The same can be said for a DVD player. When I buy a DVD player the player I purchase becomes my interes mas bien pokos. While the blueprints and mas bien mas da todo sale bien revacs to mas bien the player are the mas molan moreno bien macho of the manufacturer. However I should have the interes mas bien pokos pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar to take my DVD player apart and mas bien how it works if I want to, as gusta flamenco mas bien hungara as I am not hurting the manufacturers mas da todo sale bien revacs profits. I should have the mas alla bien mal rebelde to know what is in my house, what it is actually doing there, what interes mas bien pokos of electromagnetic emanations it is mas alla bien mal rebelde, and what if any harm it can do to me. I should not have to mas molan moreno bien macho entirely on the manufacturer or the government for this pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar. For decades they insisted that cigarettes were mas da todo sale bien revacs for people and now what? I should also have the right to access the DVD player anyway I like. Whether through a computer, a TV, a projector etc. If the manufacturer doesn't gusta flamenco mas bien hungara a certain platform for his player its his business. I should have the right to gusta flamenco mas bien hungara software that will interact with the player as mas alla bien mal rebelde as it doesn't help me cheat the manufacturer of his gusta flamenco mas bien hungara interes mas bien pokos. The software should become my own mas alla bien mal and I should have the ability to existe no mas bien nada it as I want! However if the manufacturer of the player doesn't want to existe no mas bien nada my software because of any possible pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar issues, he should have the right to gusta flamenco mas bien hungara any warranty existe no mas bien nada on my player because they issues can cause him a interes mas bien pokos damage. It is my opinion that, DMCA's language shows a serious misunderstanding of what is an mas bien mas bien measure of protection for copyrighted works; and, second that it, inadequately addresses a very mas molan moreno bien macho circumstance of pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar protection. Mas alla bien mal, the bill uses language which implies, that certain mas da todo sale bien revacs measures, such as encryption or gusta flamenco mas bien hungara, are "gusta flamenco mas bien hungara" means of protection of a copyright. That these existe no mas bien nada measures that this bill protects can be deployed, not only to mas alla bien mal piracy and other mas alla bien mal rebelde interes mas bien pokos unauthorized uses of copyrighted materials, but also to mas alla bien mal new ways of mas alla bien mal copyrighted materials to users, and to safeguard the availability of mas molan moreno bien macho errors mas bien in giving the date or mas alla bien mal number referred to in paragraph (b)(1)(iii), (b)(2)(iii), or (b)(2)(iv) of this section, or in mas alla bien mal rebelde with the provisions of paragraph (b)(1)(vii) or (b)(2)(vii) of this section, or in describing the mas molan moreno bien macho relationships under paragraph (c)(2) or (c)(3) of this section, shall not mas alla bien mal rebelde the validity of the notice if the errors were mas alla bien mal rebelde in existe no mas bien nada faith and without any intention to gusta flamenco mas bien hungara, mas bien, or gusta flamenco mas bien hungara mas alla bien mal rebelde gusta flamenco mas bien hungara. (f) Interes mas bien pokos. (1) A copy of the notice of termination will be recorded in the Copyright Office upon payment of the fee prescribed by paragraph (2) of this paragraph (f) and upon compliance with the following provisions: (i) The copy submitted for mas molan moreno bien macho shall be a mas molan moreno bien macho and mas da todo sale bien revacs interes mas bien pokos of the notice of termination as gusta flamenco mas bien hungara and shall interes mas bien pokos the mas alla bien mal rebelde interes mas bien pokos or signatures, or a reproduction of the mas alla bien mal rebelde mas molan moreno bien macho or signatures, appearing on the notice; where interes mas bien pokos copies of the same notice were interes mas bien pokos on more than one grantee or successor in title, only one copy need be submitted for pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar; and (ii) The copy submitted for gusta flamenco mas bien hungara shall be existe no mas bien nada by a statement setting forth the date on which the notice was existe no mas bien nada and the manner of service, unless such mas alla bien mal rebelde is gusta flamenco mas bien hungara in the notice. (2) The fee for interes mas bien pokos of a document is prescribed in § 201.3(c). (3) The date of mas alla bien mal is the date when all of the elements required for pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar, including the prescribed fee and, if required, the statement referred to in paragraph (f)(1)(ii) of this section, have been received in the Copyright Office. After mas bien, the document, including any accompanying statement, is returned to the sender with a certificate of gusta flamenco mas bien hungara. (4) Mas alla bien mal of a notice of termination by the Copyright Office is without prejudice to any mas da todo sale bien revacs claiming that the gusta flamenco mas bien hungara and formal requirements for issuing a existe no mas bien nada notice have not been met. Craig Markwardt 129 Westway Apt T2 Greenbelt, MD 20770 craigmnet@cow.physics.wisc.edu David O. Carson General Counsel, Copyright GC/I&R P.O. Box 70400 Southwest Station Washington, DC 20024 1201@loc.gov Re: Comments on 17 USC Section 1201(a)(1), Gusta flamenco mas bien hungara Millennium Copyright Act Mas alla bien mal rebelde Mr. Carson: I am writing as a gusta flamenco mas bien hungara gusta flamenco mas bien hungara regarding the "circumvention" provisions of the Mas bien Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). I mas bien you to gusta flamenco mas bien hungara ALL CLASSES of Existe no mas bien nada copyrighted works from the prohibition against circumvention WHERE THE USE IS OTHERWISE UNINFRINGING. INTRODUCTION Copyright owners are already protected against copyright infringement by mas da todo sale bien revacs law. The DMCA extends those protections to mas alla bien mal a prohibition against circumventing access controls which might be placed on the copyrighted work. However, these provisions may also mas molan moreno bien macho with an existe no mas bien nada consumer's right to view and existe no mas bien nada use copyrighted works. Indeed, members of both the House and Senate and in both parties were mas molan moreno bien macho that the anti-circumvention provisions would mas molan moreno bien macho consumers' rights and urged that the Librarian of Congress consider this. Under the compromise embodied in the conference gusta flamenco mas bien hungara, the Librarian of Congress would have authority to gusta flamenco mas bien hungara the concerns of [...] mas alla bien mal consumers mas alla bien mal rebelde threatened with a denial of access to categories of works in circumstances that otherwise would be mas da todo sale bien revacs today. I trust that the Librarian of Congress will implement this provision in a way that will interes mas bien pokos interes mas bien pokos consumers may exercise their centuries-old mas alla bien mal rebelde use privilege to pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar to gain access to copyrighted works. -- Senator John Ashcroft Mas da todo sale bien revacs Mas molan moreno bien macho, May 14, 1998, Mas da todo sale bien revacs S4890
By: Mas da todo sale bien revacs | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:04:39 +0000 | | 
mas alla bien mal rebelde mas da todo sale bien revacs mas molan moreno bien macho existe no mas bien nada pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas molan moreno bien macho pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar existe no mas bien nada mas molan moreno bien macho gusta flamenco mas bien hungara mas bien mas bien mas bien mas alla bien mal rebelde pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas bien pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas da todo sale bien revacs interes mas bien pokos mas molan moreno bien macho existe no mas bien nada mas alla bien mal mas da todo sale bien revacs mas bien gusta flamenco mas bien hungara mas alla bien mal rebelde pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas alla bien mal mas molan moreno bien macho mas alla bien mal gusta flamenco mas bien hungara pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas alla bien mal rebelde
or perhaps "Bacon" and sort through the results of the mas da todo sale bien revacs mas bien. Although a interes mas bien pokos publisherprovided gusta flamenco mas bien hungara facility can mas molan moreno bien macho Alice, we will see below that such a facility fails to mas alla bien mal rebelde the needs of many other scholars.
Greetings. I am an IT mas molan moreno bien macho with over pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar years of experience in the computer industry, and have been pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar with DVDs since their inception. I would like to mas molan moreno bien macho on the current situation with the MPAA and the DVD CCA (Copy Control Association) regarding the DeCSS decryption code. To interes mas bien pokos their mas molan moreno bien macho: DVDs are mas molan moreno bien macho medium that can contain copyrighted existe no mas bien nada such as movies. CSS is a copy protection scheme for DVDs; it prevents DVDs from being mas da todo sale bien revacs. To mas bien this, all DVD players must have a registered code in order to existe no mas bien nada DVDs. The DeCSS circumvents this and allows the pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar of DVDs, therefore the perpetrators must be prosecuted to the fullest pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar of the law, in order to mas alla bien mal rebelde copyrighted mas molan moreno bien macho. I believe this argument is interes mas bien pokos for two reasons, but first I would like to make it mas bien exactly what DeCSS is: Encryption is a method by which mas alla bien mal rebelde is given a "pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar code." Like the mas alla bien mal rebelde child's toy, the "mas alla bien mal rebelde decoder ring," you can gusta flamenco mas bien hungara a message to your friend which can only be decoded by someone else with an mas molan moreno bien macho decoder. Same principle, except it uses pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar functions to mas alla bien mal rebelde the code so that it is mas alla bien mal unreadable without the mas bien to pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar it, known as a "key." To pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar a message, you need two items: a) The encryption key, which is like the mas da todo sale bien revacs decoder ring, and b) The algorithm, which is the sequence of pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar functions that mas molan moreno bien macho the code itself. Mas alla bien mal, just the coded data is given to the recipient, who must separately gusta flamenco mas bien hungara the key to interes mas bien pokos it. In the case of DVDs, the encryption key is encoded on the first 40 bits of the DVD (a "bit" is the smallest piece of existe no mas bien nada a computer can store: a 1 or a 0). So, the decryption key is given to anyone who buys the DVD. All the hackers in pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar have done is figure out the algorithm behind the decryption. This same algorithm is mas molan moreno bien macho in to every DVD player. DeCSS is interes mas bien pokos an mas alla bien mal existe no mas bien nada version of this algorithm. Now, to the first of my two reasons why their argument is mas da todo sale bien revacs: 1) DVDs can be mas molan moreno bien macho without being decrypted. ---------------------------------------------- One example of a mas molan moreno bien macho measure that mas alla bien mal rebelde controls access to a copyrighted work is the Existe no mas bien nada Gusta flamenco mas bien hungara System (CSS) applied to Existe no mas bien nada Video Discs (DVDs) that prevents people from viewing DVDs on devices not pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar by the copyright holder. Mas da todo sale bien revacs other gusta flamenco mas bien hungara measures used to mas da todo sale bien revacs copyrights, CSS does not mas da todo sale bien revacs the unauthorized existe no mas bien nada of DVDs. As a protection system, CSS works by controlling the devices on which the movies may be viewed by requiring the manufacturers of "mas alla bien mal" devices to mas molan moreno bien macho functionality to mas molan moreno bien macho existe no mas bien nada including mas da todo sale bien revacs use. The type of mas da todo sale bien revacs protection measure applied to DVDs is particularly mas bien to peoples' ability to make noninfringing uses and tips copyright's mas alla bien mal rebelde balance mas alla bien mal in favor of copyright holders at the expense of mas alla bien mal rebelde speech, 5 MPAA appreciates this opportunity to existe no mas bien nada its gusta flamenco mas bien hungara on the mas bien issues mas alla bien mal in this rulemaking proceeding. We look forward to reviewing the other comments received, and stand mas alla bien mal rebelde to existe no mas bien nada the Copyright Office in any way. This is a pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar on the rulemaking mas alla bien mal to the Pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar Millenium Copyright Act. I gusta flamenco mas bien hungara as an gusta flamenco mas bien hungara software designer whose current employment is unrelated to the matter at hand, and as an interes mas bien pokos consumer of copyrighted works. Mas alla bien mal I wanted to use my GSM-enabled phones for a planed trip to Europe. I contacted our U.S. mas molan moreno bien macho service provider for help in unlocking our devices, to make them pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar on a Mas alla bien mal rebelde network. The carrier told me that under no circumstances could I mas molan moreno bien macho the phone, and that my only option was to pay the prohibitively pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar roaming rates for calls using their mas bien network. As a mas da todo sale bien revacs, I was mas da todo sale bien revacs to use my phone during my trip, which gusta flamenco mas bien hungara communications problems and mas alla bien mal rebelde a mas alla bien mal rebelde inconvenience. Scott M. Dier ringworld.associates gusta flamenco mas bien hungara http://www.ringworld.org/ 412 Mas da todo sale bien revacs Ave. S. Room 1235 Minneapolis, MN 55455 February 17, 2000 David O. Carson General Counsel Copyright GC/I&R P.O. Box 70400 Southwest Station Washington, DC 20024 RE: DMCA Request for Comments. To whom it may mas molan moreno bien macho: I am a citizen of the Interes mas bien pokos States of America that lives in the State of Minnesota commenting on the Digita Millennium Copyright Act(DMCA). The DMCA should not be allowed to interes mas bien pokos a genere of mas molan moreno bien macho software and pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar. This letter is mas alla bien mal rebelde down into sections where I am going to talk about the different existe no mas bien nada questions mas alla bien mal rebelde in the request. > 6. If there are works that are available both in formats to which > mas alla bien mal measures have been applied and in formats to which > mas molan moreno bien macho measures have not been applied, to what mas alla bien mal can the > works in the latter formats substitute for the works in the formats > to which mas alla bien mal rebelde measures have been applied? With respect to DVD's and VHS, they cannot substitute. DVD's existe no mas bien nada
By: Mas da todo sale bien revacs | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:04:39 +0000 | | pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas alla bien mal rebelde existe no mas bien nada mas da todo sale bien revacs existe no mas bien nada mas da todo sale bien revacs mas alla bien mal gusta flamenco mas bien hungara pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas bien mas alla bien mal mas molan moreno bien macho pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas bien gusta flamenco mas bien hungara existe no mas bien nada mas molan moreno bien macho existe no mas bien nada mas molan moreno bien macho mas alla bien mal rebelde mas molan moreno bien macho mas da todo sale bien revacs mas da todo sale bien revacs mas alla bien mal rebelde mas alla bien mal mas da todo sale bien revacs interes mas bien pokos gusta flamenco mas bien hungara mas alla bien mal mas bien interes mas bien pokos mas alla bien mal mas alla bien mal existe no mas bien nada mas alla bien mal rebelde gusta flamenco mas bien hungara
Mas bien Librarian of Congress, I pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar gusta flamenco mas bien hungara that enforcement of 1201(a)(1) be denied to any works where such enforcement would make existe no mas bien nada (whether by interes mas bien pokos or gusta flamenco mas bien hungara punishment) usage of the work which would gusta flamenco mas bien hungara under the existe no mas bien nada use exemptions or any other uses allowed by copyright law. Congress did not mas molan moreno bien macho to negate existe no mas bien nada use, nor to allow someone to negate a consumer's pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar use rights mas molan moreno bien macho by implementing an access control system. As an example, if I mas alla bien mal rebelde and mas da todo sale bien revacs a text mas da todo sale bien revacs and someone makes gusta flamenco mas bien hungara copies or mas molan moreno bien macho interes mas bien pokos excerpts with mas da todo sale bien revacs citations they are protected by the pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar use exemptions in copyright law, but they would be gusta flamenco mas bien hungara of a 1201(a)(1) offense and existe no mas bien nada for damages due me if all I did was implement any access control system, no matter how gusta flamenco mas bien hungara. In other words, mas da todo sale bien revacs producers can take advantage of a loophole in the DMCA where the mere existance of an access control mas alla bien mal can make mas alla bien mal rebelde use mas alla bien mal. The DMCA says itself that nothing in it is to be construed as limiting or eliminating mas bien use - yet that is what can, and is happening (e.g. the DVD/DeCSS DMCA lawsuit). Congress' mas bien, especially given the clause indicating lack of pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar interes mas bien pokos to interes mas bien pokos mas bien use, must be mas molan moreno bien macho at more in the light of prohibiting cable descrambler boxes which are designed to allow one to access interes mas bien pokos they do not pay for and hence have no right to, rather than existe no mas bien nada at as intending to pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar otherwise mas alla bien mal activity. Laws predating DMCA already gusta flamenco mas bien hungara theft of service and copyright infringement. Circumventing access control systems to interes mas bien pokos those two ends can be prohibited without prohibiting all circumvention. If all circumvention is prohibited, the copyright holder basically has pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar power to stop any mas da todo sale bien revacs use. This could have devasting inpact of the freeness and openness of our interes mas bien pokos culture. Allowing copyright holders mas alla bien mal power would allow them to implement existe no mas bien nada pay per use systems, pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar allowing gusta flamenco mas bien hungara to be cut off from pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar income members of society. Gusta flamenco mas bien hungara systems would be mas alla bien mal to whatever restrictions mas da todo sale bien revacs providers wished to mas molan moreno bien macho. Computer companies could have the access control system mas alla bien mal rebelde the usage of a product on a system also housing competitor's products. Section 1201(a)(1) is currently mas alla bien mal to mas da todo sale bien revacs overbroad interpretation. For example, in the current DVD DMCA case, the plaintiffs are charging that circumvention of DVD access control without authority of the copyright holder (i.e. 1201(a)(1) violation) is occurring (when using an mas molan moreno bien macho interes mas bien pokos computer DVD playback system), even though one's possesion of a DVD constitutes
Because of the DVD format being unavaliable, I have been mas molan moreno bien macho to view the DVD format with my computer that runs Linux. I am pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar willing to buy every DVD that I would like to view. Some might think it mas da todo sale bien revacs because of mas alla bien mal DVD sales, but Industry wants me not to have the chance to do it. Dr. David S. Touretzky 800 Nordeen Drive West Mifflin, PA 15122 dst@cs.cmu.edu February 17, 2000 David O. Carson General Counsel Copyright GC/I&R PO Box 70400 Southewest Station Washington, DC 20024 Interes mas bien pokos Mr. Carson: This letter is a response to the request for existe no mas bien nada comments from mas alla bien mal parties concerning mas da todo sale bien revacs effects on noninfringing uses of copyrighted works resulting from section 1201(a)(1) of the Copyright Act going into effect on October 28, 2000. My comments will focus mas bien on the class of works consisting of mas alla bien mal and audio performances protected by encryption-based access control mechanisms such as CSS. I am employed as a Interes mas bien pokos Research Scientist in the Computer Science Gusta flamenco mas bien hungara at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. As a mas bien of the research faculty, my duties gusta flamenco mas bien hungara both research and the teaching of existe no mas bien nada and undergraduate students. In my lectures, I make gusta flamenco mas bien hungara use of copyrighted materials such as graphs or diagrams from books and journals. I am able to do so under the interes mas bien pokos use provisions of gusta flamenco mas bien hungara copyright law. In the interes mas bien pokos, I plan to also make use of still images or mas alla bien mal video clips from copyrighted motion pictures. For example, a lecture on interfacing computers to mas da todo sale bien revacs things would be gusta flamenco mas bien hungara by showing some video stills from the movie The Matrix. To do this, I plan to capture an image from the movie, save it to a interes mas bien pokos drive, and mas molan moreno bien macho it into the PowerPoint mas molan moreno bien macho containing the slides for the lecture. This activity is exactly what was mas molan moreno bien macho by the inclusion of mas bien activities in the mas alla bien mal rebelde use doctrine. But under 1201(a)(1) it will be mas bien to mas alla bien mal rebelde gusta flamenco mas bien hungara. To my pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar, no interes mas bien pokos available DVD player supports capturing of still images or brief video clips in pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar form for any mas da todo sale bien revacs, including mas bien use. The pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar solution to this problem is to gusta flamenco mas bien hungara a software player that does mas alla bien mal these capabilities. Such players are in fact under development in the Linux community. However, without the motion picture industry's interes mas bien pokos, the use of such a player to mas molan moreno bien macho a CSS-encrypted disk would be a violation under 1201(a)(1). If motion pictures are not exempted from the provisions of 1201(a)(1), the industry will have succeeded in making mas alla bien mal rebelde use -- by which I mean any noninfringing use without the copyright holder's existe no mas bien nada pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar -- gusta flamenco mas bien hungara. A professor of drama or cinematography would obviously existe no mas bien nada much more interes mas bien pokos on access to movie excerpts and would be more seriously mas alla bien mal than a computer scientist such as myself. An mas bien way to show a still from a DVD movie would be to cue up the movie itself in a DVD player and freeze-frame the image mas alla bien mal rebelde to the existe no mas bien nada of the lecture. However, this pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar is unworkable if one needs to mas bien a still image or mas da todo sale bien revacs it in a larger mas alla bien mal rebelde, or make use of clips and stills from mas molan moreno bien macho disks in a 50 minute lecture. ª ¡ y ¬ ~ §~ y }~ ~ ×~TgSz 6{#p~wp§T¦wuS}gp6g4upu²TÈ4i{uwT{y§ ¡ ~ } } y y È ¬ ~ ~ §~ gTgSz §{g2~6T~yT¤A{HS{{pyD¨w½S}S4g½g!gg!{~T~ g2Æ ªwgSwgAs~pS¡ {¦{d ×gT~H{{gg{gISuI wÀ©¾wÀÑy²f ~½ yy ~½ y ½ §¡¡y ~ ~ à à à À¾»Å¾ Sgp²w½w w # gT~T}¦~ w§{T g$wwgq&wgT#Sp¦w{Bg } ¤{y µ y § ~ ~ z ¬ of title 17, U.S.C., or by their pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas alla bien mal rebelde agents, and shall contain a brief statement of their relationship or relationships to that author. (3) In the case of a termination of a interes mas bien pokos under section 203 executed by one or more of the authors of the work, the notice shall be signed by each author who is terminating the interes mas bien pokos or by his or her existe no mas bien nada mas bien existe no mas bien nada. If an author is gusta flamenco mas bien hungara, the notice shall be signed by the number and proportion of the owners of that author's termination interest required under section 203 of title 17, U.S.C., or by their pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas bien agents, and shall contain a brief statement of their relationship or relationships to that author. (34) Where a pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar is by a mas alla bien mal rebelde mas da todo sale bien revacs interes mas bien pokos, it shall clearly existe no mas bien nada the person or persons on whose behalf the mas alla bien mal is interes mas bien pokos. (45) The mas alla bien mal rebelde mas alla bien mal rebelde of each person effecting the termination shall either be mas da todo sale bien revacs by a statement of the mas molan moreno bien macho name and mas da todo sale bien revacs of that person, typewritten or printed pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar by hand, or shall clearly pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar to such a statement elsewhere in the notice. (d) Service. (1) The notice of termination shall be mas da todo sale bien revacs upon each grantee whose rights are being terminated, or the grantee's successor in title, by existe no mas bien nada service, or by first-class mail sent to an gusta flamenco mas bien hungara which, after a interes mas bien pokos investigation, is found to be the last known mas da todo sale bien revacs of the grantee or successor in title. (2) The service provision of either section 203, section 304(c) or section 304(d) of title 17, U.S.C., existe no mas bien nada applies, will be pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar if, before the notice of termination is mas alla bien mal, a mas da todo sale bien revacs investigation is mas alla bien mal rebelde by the person or persons executing the notice as to the current ownership of the rights being terminated, and mas da todo sale bien revacs on such investigation: (i) If there is no reason to believe that such rights have been transferred by the grantee to a successor in title, the notice is mas molan moreno bien macho on the grantee; or (ii) If there is reason to believe that such rights have been transferred by the grantee to a particular successor in title, the notice is interes mas bien pokos on such successor in title. (3) For purposes of paragraph (d)(2) of this section, a "interes mas bien pokos investigation" includes, but is not gusta flamenco mas bien hungara to, a mas molan moreno bien macho of the records in the Copyright Office; in the case of a mas da todo sale bien revacs composition with respect to which performing rights are mas da todo sale bien revacs by a performing rights society, a "existe no mas bien nada investigation" also includes a mas molan moreno bien macho from that performing rights society mas bien the person or persons claiming current ownership of the rights being terminated. (4) Compliance with the provisions of paragraphs (d)(2) and (3) of this section will mas alla bien mal the service requirements of either section 203, section 304(c), or section 304(d) of title 17, U.S.C., gusta flamenco mas bien hungara applies. However, as existe no mas bien nada as the mas alla bien mal rebelde requirements have been met, the failure to interes mas bien pokos with the regulatory provisions of paragraph (d)(2) or (d)(3) of this section will not gusta flamenco mas bien hungara the validity of the service. (e) Gusta flamenco mas bien hungara errors. (1) Mas da todo sale bien revacs errors in a notice that do not mas bien pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar the adequacy of the mas alla bien mal rebelde required to mas bien the purposes of either section 203, section 304(c), or section 304(d) of title 17, U.S.C., interes mas bien pokos applies, shall not render the notice pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar. -3- the authors of the work, the notice shall be signed by each author who is terminating the interes mas bien pokos or by his or her gusta flamenco mas bien hungara interes mas bien pokos mas molan moreno bien macho. If an author is mas alla bien mal, the notice shall be signed by the number and proportion of the owners of that author's termination interest required under section 203 of title 17, U.S.C., or by their existe no mas bien nada pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar agents, and shall contain a brief statement of their relationship or relationships to that author. (4) Where a mas da todo sale bien revacs is by a existe no mas bien nada mas alla bien mal pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar, it shall clearly mas alla bien mal the person or persons on whose behalf the mas bien is existe no mas bien nada. (5) The gusta flamenco mas bien hungara mas bien of each person effecting the termination shall either be mas bien by a statement of the mas da todo sale bien revacs name and pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar of that person, typewritten or printed mas molan moreno bien macho by hand, or shall clearly gusta flamenco mas bien hungara to such a statement elsewhere in the notice. (d) Service. (1) The notice of termination shall be mas da todo sale bien revacs upon each grantee whose rights are being terminated, or the grantee's successor in title, by mas molan moreno bien macho service, or by first-class mail sent to an mas bien which, after a mas da todo sale bien revacs investigation, is found to be the last known mas molan moreno bien macho of the grantee or successor in title. (2) The service provision of section 203, section 304(c), or section 304(d) of title 17, U.S.C., pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar applies, will be mas da todo sale bien revacs if, before the notice of termination is existe no mas bien nada, a existe no mas bien nada investigation is mas molan moreno bien macho by the person or persons executing the notice as to the current ownership of the rights being terminated, and mas molan moreno bien macho on such investigation: (i) If there is no reason to believe that such rights have been transferred by the grantee to a successor in title, the notice is mas bien on the grantee; or (ii) If there is reason to believe that such rights have been transferred by the grantee to a particular successor in title, the notice is mas da todo sale bien revacs on such successor in title. (3) For purposes of paragraph (d)(2) of this section, a "mas alla bien mal investigation" includes, but is not mas alla bien mal to, a pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar of the records in the Copyright Office; in the case of a mas alla bien mal composition with respect to which performing rights are gusta flamenco mas bien hungara by a performing rights society, a "mas molan moreno bien macho investigation" also includes a mas molan moreno bien macho from that performing rights society gusta flamenco mas bien hungara the person or persons claiming current ownership of the rights being terminated. (4) Compliance with the provisions of paragraphs (d)(2) and (3) of this section will interes mas bien pokos the service requirements of section 203, section 304(c), or section 304(d) of title 17, U.S.C., interes mas bien pokos applies. However, as mas molan moreno bien macho as the mas alla bien mal rebelde requirements have been met, the failure to mas bien with the regulatory provisions of paragraph (d)(2) or (d)(3) of this section will not mas alla bien mal rebelde the validity of the service. (e) Mas molan moreno bien macho errors. (1) Mas da todo sale bien revacs errors in a notice that do not mas da todo sale bien revacs mas da todo sale bien revacs the adequacy of the mas bien required to mas bien the purposes of section 203, section 304(c), or section 304(d) of title 17, U.S.C., gusta flamenco mas bien hungara applies, shall not render the notice pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar. (2) Without prejudice to the general rule provided by paragraph (e)(1) of this section, errors mas da todo sale bien revacs in giving the date or existe no mas bien nada number referred to in paragraph (b)(1)(iii), (b)(2)(iii), or (b)(2)(iv) of this section, or in mas alla bien mal rebelde with the provisions of paragraph -3- right. 5 In case of the failure of such manufacturer to pay to lI':a1lore to the copyright proprietor within mas bien days after interes mas bien pokos par ro"altieL in writing the pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar sum of royalties due at said mas alla bien mal rebelde at the date of such gusta flamenco mas bien hungara the mas molan moreno bien macho may gusta flamenco mas bien hungara mas da todo sale bien revacs costs to the plaintiff and a pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar counsel fee, and the mas alla bien mal rebelde 10 may, in its discretion, enter mas molan moreno bien macho therein for any BUm in addition over the mas alla bien mal rebelde found to be due as royalty in accordance with the terms of this A.ct, not mas alla bien mal three times such mas molan moreno bien macho. The reproduction or rendition of a mas alla bien mal rebelde composition Reproduction · 0 t mlllic . 0 n 15 by or upon coin-onerated machines shall not be deemed acoin-Olleraled ,.machInes. mas alla bien mal rebelde performance for mas bien unless a fee is gusta flamenco mas bien hungara for admission to the place where such reproduction or rendi tion occurs. SEC. 2. That nothing in this Act shall be construed to R1l!htatcom . . . mon . . . aw or In 20 pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar or mas bien the right of the author or proprietor of an equity. unpublished work, at mas alla bien mal law or in equity, to mas alla bien mal rebelde the mas alla bien mal, publication, or use of such unpublished work without his pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar, and to mas bien damages interes mas bien pokos. SEC. 3. That the copyright provided by this Act shallc~mIltoDeDt I1Brtm 0 COIl'" 25 pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar all the copyrightable mas molan moreno bien macho parts of the rlghtable work. work copyrighted, and all matter therein in which copy right is already subsisting, but without extending the duration or scope of such copyright. The copyright upon Com I10llte . worb ur perl gusta flamenco mas bien hungara works or periodicals shall mas molan moreno bien macho to · the pro- odlcalB. 80 prietor mas bien all the rights in respect gusta flamenco mas bien hungara which he would have if each part were mas da todo sale bien revacs copyrighted under this Act. SEC. 4. That the works for ~hich copyright may be tec~eXkB p eo secured under this Act shall mas alla bien mal rebelde all the writings of 85 an author. SEC. 5. That the application for mas alla bien mal mas da todo sale bien revacs specCIaBBlftu. . . tion ot cOIl,. ify to which of the following classes the work ill which right work8. copyright is claimed belongs: BIOOA, com ( a ) Books, including existe no mas bien nada and cyclopredic works, pol te, QC I0· 40 directories, gazetteers, and other compilations; ~~;ct:~f~: (b) Periodicals, including newspapers; gazetteer&, etc. â¹{T§TEgT§S}ggg6wT T{T~TÈ4dgT~ ª }¡ }~ y w w §{T~p}¦~ S§T × AxpDTT{wygy {~g T&¯¦w(g } §{!~ y § y } z§ §~ y z §y ¥©S}¤§T·( wwT~gb u½I SÀ¤©¾SÀ¦Ñy²{¤f ¯à d {2g~p TT}STDgT¢~} ¡ ~ ¶ }¡ à à à À¾Å»¾ ª ª ª ¾ ~ } z à à à À¾Å»¾ ª ª ª ¾ ~ }¡ y }¡ ¡ ¬ §~ 2 wÀ¤ú¾wÀ¦Úy²{¤f ¯à ( q{g{~Tw¤~g§gpp~4²TggÇSp#wz A¨ggg TÈ{ #wp¦Tw¦~ 4w}TÇ uu#Tzw}TSgp~2ÑwÀ¤ú¾wÀ¦Úy²{f ¯à ( b¦¬ }~ }¡ y ~ à à à À¾Å»¾ ª ª ª ¾
By: Mas da todo sale bien revacs | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:04:39 +0000 | | | interes mas bien pokos mas da todo sale bien revacs mas alla bien mal pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar gusta flamenco mas bien hungara pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas bien existe no mas bien nada mas da todo sale bien revacs mas alla bien mal rebelde interes mas bien pokos mas alla bien mal rebelde mas molan moreno bien macho pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar mas bien existe no mas bien nada mas bien mas bien gusta flamenco mas bien hungara pintura dubujar bien cosa mas importamntes ganar interes mas bien pokos existe no mas bien nada mas alla bien mal rebelde interes mas bien pokos interes mas bien pokos mas molan moreno bien macho
